QUICK ANSWER
To tell if a website is legit, start with the web address and make sure it matches the real brand exactly, with no extra words or swapped letters. From there, look for a real street address and phone number, return and shipping policies with actual timeframes, and the option to pay by credit card. A store that passes one of these checks isn’t automatically safe, but one that fails several, or pushes you to pay with a gift card, wire transfer, or crypto, is one to walk away from.
Key takeaways
- The padlock icon in your address bar only means your connection is encrypted. Scam stores can have one too, so it’s not a definitive sign the seller is honest.
- Check the web address letter by letter. Scam stores often copy a real brand’s name and add a word like “outlet” or change a single letter.
- A brand-new site with huge discounts and no reviews anywhere else is worth a second look before you buy.
- Reviews on the store’s own site don’t count. Look for what real shoppers are saying on sites the store doesn’t control.
- Paying by credit card gives you the most options if something goes wrong. If a store wants a gift card, wire transfer, or crypto, that’s your cue to leave.
- Already paid a store you’re now unsure about? Call your card issuer first, using the number on the back of your card.
You found a sweater on a site you’ve never heard of, and it’s $29 when every other store you’ve checked has it for $89. The checkout page is one click away, and you’re wondering whether this is a lucky find or a stranger about to get your card number.
It’s a smart thing to stop and ask, especially in the weeks before the holidays when scam stores show up everywhere. These sites are built to look like the real thing, but they almost always get something wrong, and once you know where to look, those mistakes are pretty easy to catch.
This guide walks you through how to check an online store before you buy, so you can use the same steps on any site that asks for your card number. If you’re trying to figure out whether a link from a text or email is safe, that’s a slightly different check.
For the bigger picture, start with our guide to online shopping scams.
How to tell if a website is legit in 60 seconds
Before you type in your card number, take a minute to run through these six quick checks. If something looks off, the sections below dig into each one in more detail.
The web address matches the brand. No extra words, swapped letters, or odd endings.
There's real contact information. A street address and a phone number or email you can reach.
Return and shipping policies are clear. Specific timeframes, not vague promises.
Payment options include a credit card. And do not push you to gift cards, wire transfers, or crypto.
Independent reviews exist. On sites the store doesn't control.
The price makes sense. Compare it with two stores you already trust.
If a site fails one check, look closer. If it fails three or more, close the tab.
How to check the web address and domain age
Start with the address bar. Scam stores often copy a real brand's name and change a little. That trick is called website spoofing, and it's closely related to phishing. An extra hyphen, a word like "outlet" or "deals," a swapped letter, or an unusual ending are all common tricks. The surest habit is to type the store's name into your browser yourself instead of tapping an ad or message link.
Does the padlock mean a website is safe?
Not on its own. The padlock, or the “https” at the start of a web address, means the connection between your browser and the site is encrypted, so the information you send can’t easily be read along the way. That’s useful, but it doesn’t tell you anything about who’s on the other end. Scam stores can get a padlock just as easily as real ones, and many do. So think of it as the bare minimum a store should have, then keep checking before you trust it with your card number.
How old should a store's website be?
There’s no set number, but a website’s age can tell you a lot when you compare it to what the store says about itself. You can look it up with a free tool like ICANN Lookup. Type in the store’s web address, and if the registration details are available, you’ll see when the address was first registered. If a store says it’s been in business for 10 years but its website was registered a few weeks ago, that may be a sign of a scam. Still, a new site isn’t automatically a scam, and an older one isn’t automatically safe, so treat the age as one clue and weigh it alongside everything else on this list.
What contact details and policies a real store should have
A real store wants to be reachable, so a site having no contact details is a red flag.
Look for these four things:
A physical business address you can look up on a map.
A phone number or email that is specific to the business, not just a form to fill out.
A return policy with a timeframe and the steps to follow.
A shipping policy with carriers and estimated delivery windows.
Scam stores often leave these out or paste text that doesn't match the site.
Try this
copy a sentence from the return policy and search for it in quotes. If the same words show up on a dozen unrelated sites, the policy was likely copied.
What if there's no contact page at all?
Take that as a strong reason to slow down. Before you rule the store out, scroll to the very bottom of the page and check the footer, the “About” page, and the order FAQ, since some smaller shops tuck their details there. If you still can’t find a way to reach the company, it’s best to shop somewhere else. A store that’s happy to take your money but gives you no way to contact it leaves you with nowhere to turn if your order never shows up.
Which Payment Options Are a Red Flag, and Which Protect You?
How a store asks you to pay says a lot. Walk away if a store pushes you toward gift cards, wire transfers, cryptocurrency, or a payment app. The FTC says anyone who demands payment by gift card is likely a scammer.1
In fact, back in 2024, consumers reported losing more money to scams where they paid with bank transfers or cryptocurrency than all other payment methods combined, according to the FTC's March 2025 release.2
Credit cards come with dispute rights, which automatically makes them a much safer method of payment. Federal law lets you dispute billing errors, including charges for goods you never received, if you notify your card issuer within 60 days of the statement showing the charge.3 Limits and conditions apply, so check your issuer's own guidance.
Debit cards, bank transfers, and payment apps work under different rules, and the apps have their own pages, including PayPal and Venmo. Our video on whether your bank will refund you if you're scammed explains the differences in further detail.
Will My Bank Refund Me If I Get Scammed? Why "Authorized" Payments Usually Aren't Covered
No payment method can undo a bad purchase completely, and no one can promise you’ll get your money back. But the way you pay decides how much help you can get if something goes wrong. Paying by credit card gives you a real path to dispute the charge, while a gift card or wire transfer usually leaves you with very few options once the money is gone. So if a store you’re unsure about only accepts the riskier payment methods, that alone is a good reason to shop somewhere else.
Not sure if a store is real?
Scam stores are built to look like the real thing, right down to the checkout page. OmniWatch Scam Protection helps you check suspicious links, texts, and emails before you buy.
Explore Scam ProtectionHow to read reviews the right way
Reviews are one of the first things most of us check before buying from a new store, and scammers know it. That’s why fake stores often fill their pages with glowing five-star ratings, made-up customer photos, and comments that sound a little too perfect. Reviews can still be really useful, but only if you know where to find honest ones and how to spot the ones that were written to sell you something.
Here’s how to read them with a healthy dose of skepticism.
Ignore reviews on the store's own site as proof. The store controls what appears and can easily hide negative reviews.
Look for independent sources. Search for the store's name along with "reviews" and "scam," and look at sites the store doesn't run. BBB Scam Tracker is one place to see reports.4
Watch for patterns. Dozens of five-star reviews posted within a day, identical phrasing, or reviews that never mention the actual product are common signs of manufactured praise.
Check the company's name plus "scam" or "complaint" before you buy from an ad. That's the FTC's advice for shopping from social media ads.5
Read the one-star reviews. Look for the same complaint repeated: "never arrived," "charged twice," "no response."
The same checks apply during big sales. Our guide to Black Friday and Cyber Monday scams shows how fake deal sites try to beat them.
Protection for identity theft, scams, and losses banks won't cover
Standard plan
$7.99
per month
$143.88 $95.88 annually
Save 33%
Select planSee features
Essential monitoring with up to $2M* identity theft insurance and $50K* in scam and ransomware reimbursement
Essential monitoring
- Dark web monitoring
- Data breach notifications
- Malware alerts
- Phishing alerts
- 1 Bureau Credit Monitoring with Instant Alerts**
Financial protection
- Up to $2M in identity theft insurance*
- Up to $50,000 in scam and ransomware reimbursement*
Household Insurance
Scam protection
- AI-powered scam detection tools
Support
- 24/7 identity theft restoration support
- Expert scam agents on call
- Award-winning customer support
Additional monitoring
- Name and address monitoring
- SSN monitoring
- Digital Footprint monitoring
- 1-bureau monthly credit report**
- Daily credit score updates**
Payday Loan Monitoring and Alerts**Home Title Monitoring**
Identity protection tools
- TransUnion® Instant Credit Lock**
- Antivirus (1 device)
- VPN (2 devices)
Malware Blocking
Elite plan
$14.99
per month
$263.88 $179.88 annually
Save 31%
Select planSee features
Essential monitoring with up to $4M* identity theft insurance and $100K* in scam and ransomware reimbursement
Essential monitoring
- Dark web monitoring
- Data breach notifications
- Malware alerts
- Phishing alerts
- 3 Bureau Credit Monitoring with Instant Alerts**
Financial protection
- Up to $4M in identity theft insurance*
- Up to $100,000 in scam and ransomware reimbursement*
Household Insurance
Scam protection
- AI-powered scam detection tools
Support
- 24/7 identity theft restoration support
- Expert scam agents on call
- Award-winning customer support
Additional monitoring
- Name and address monitoring
- SSN monitoring
- Digital Footprint monitoring
- 3-bureau quarterly credit report**
- Daily credit score updates**
- Payday Loan Monitoring and Alerts**
- Home Title Monitoring**
Identity protection tools
- TransUnion® Instant Credit Lock**
- Antivirus (3 device)
- Advanced VPN (2 devices)
- Malware Blocking
Family plan
$19.99
per month
$359.88 $239.88 annually
Save 33%
Select planSee features
Essential monitoring with up to $8M* identity theft insurance and $200K* in scam and ransomware reimbursement
Essential monitoring
- Dark web monitoring
- Data breach notifications
- Malware alerts
- Phishing alerts
- 3 Bureau Credit Monitoring with Instant Alerts**
Financial protection
- Up to $8M in identity theft insurance*
- Up to $200,000 in scam and ransomware reimbursement*
- Household Insurance
Scam protection
- AI-powered scam detection tools
Support
- 24/7 identity theft restoration support
- Expert scam agents on call
- Award-winning customer support
Additional monitoring
- Name and address monitoring
- SSN monitoring
- Digital Footprint monitoring
- 3-bureau quarterly credit report**
- Daily credit score updates**
- Payday Loan Monitoring and Alerts**
- Home Title Monitoring**
Identity protection tools
- TransUnion® Instant Credit Lock**
- Antivirus (3 device)
- Advanced VPN (2 devices)
- Malware Blocking
Is a Popular Store Like TikTok Shop, AliExpress, Shein, or Temu Safe?
Well-known shopping apps and marketplaces raise a different question, because you’re often not buying from the company itself. On sites like these, many products come from independent sellers, and quality, shipping times, and return policies can vary a lot from one seller to the next. That’s why the checks in this guide still apply, even on a platform you recognize. Look at the individual seller’s ratings, read their return policy, and pay with a method that gives you protection.
If you’re curious about a specific platform, you can dig into whether TikTok Shop is safe, whether AliExpress is safe, whether Shein is legit, whether Temu is safe, and whether DHgate is safe.
What Should You Do If You Already Paid?
If you've already paid a store you now doubt. Here is what you should do:
Contact your card issuer with the number on the back of your card. Explain what happened and ask about your options.
Save the evidence, such as screenshots of the listing, your order confirmation, and any messages between you and the seller.
Change reused passwords and turn on multi-factor authentication.
Watch your bank statements for charges you don't recognize.
Fake stores aren’t always the end of the scam. Some use a store-like website as a starting point for something else, like a fake job offer designed to collect your personal information. If a “store” ever reaches out about work, especially a role that involves receiving and reshipping packages, learn how holiday job and reshipping scams work before you reply. And if you want to see every way scammers target shoppers, this guide to online shopping scams covers the full picture.
Take a minute before you check out

Most scam stores fall apart under just a little scrutiny, which is why a quick check before you buy goes such a long way. If the web address matches the brand, the store is easy to reach, the policies are clear, and you can pay by credit card, you’re in a much better spot. And if something feels off, trust that instinct. A deal that looks too good to pass up is rarely worth the risk of handing your card number to a site you can’t verify, especially when the same item is waiting at a store you already know.
Check a Suspicious Link With OmniWatch
If a store's link reached you by text or email, you can submit it to OmniWatch's AI Scam Checker to see whether it looks likely safe, unverified, likely spam, or a scam. It is a manual check you run yourself and it cannot prove a store is trustworthy, so keep using the checklist above.
Frequently asked questions
Is a website with a padlock icon safe?
A padlock means the connection to the site is encrypted, not that the seller is honest. Scam sites can display one too. Treat it as a basic requirement, then check the web address, contact details, policies, payment options, and independent reviews before you enter a card number.
How old should a website be before I trust it?
There's no magic number. A public domain registration lookup can show when an address was registered, and a very new site with deep discounts deserves extra caution. A young site isn't automatically a scam, and an old one isn't automatically safe, so weigh age alongside everything else.
Can I trust the reviews on the store's own site?
Treat them with caution, since the store controls what appears. Look for independent reviews on sites it doesn't run, watch for identical wording or a sudden burst of five-star ratings, and read the one-star reviews for repeated complaints such as items that never arrived.
How do I check if a website is a scam for free?
Run through the checklist: read the web address, find real contact details, read the policies, check independent reviews, and compare the price elsewhere. With an OmniWatch subscription, you can also submit a link to our AI Scam Checker, which shows whether it looks likely safe, unverified, likely spam, or a scam. It is a signal, not proof. Read more about our scam protection feature.
What do I do if I ordered from a fake site?
Call your card issuer using the number on your card, save your evidence, change reused passwords, and report it to the FTC fraud center. No one can promise a refund, but acting quickly gives you the most options. Watch your statements closely afterward.
This guide is published by OmniWatch, an identity and scam protection company. Follow OmniWatch on LinkedIn for ongoing guidance on identity protection and digital safety.
Sources
1. Federal Trade Commission, "Gift Card Scams". https://www.ftc.gov/giftcards
2. Federal Trade Commission, "New FTC Data Show a Big Jump in Reported Losses to Fraud to $12.5 Billion in 2024," March 10, 2025. https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/news/press-releases/2025/03/new-ftc-data-show-big-jump-reported-losses-fraud-125-billion-2024
3. Cornell Law School Legal Information Institute, 15 U.S.C. § 1666, Correction of billing errors. https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/15/1666
4. Better Business Bureau, BBB Scam Tracker. https://www.bbb.org/scamtracker
5. Federal Trade Commission Consumer Alert, "Are ads on social media vetted or checked for scams? Here's what to know," August 2026. https://consumer.ftc.gov/consumer-alerts/2026/08/are-ads-social-media-vetted-or-checked-scams-heres-what-know